Something as simple as setting up stone walls has always intrigued man due to the natural beauty of stones. But when building your stacked stone wall, you'll encounter two primary construction methods: Dry stack stone and wet lay stone. Another difference is between the dry-stack stone and the wet-laid stone. Both have advantages and disadvantages, and their successful planning depends on several factors. In this blog, you’ll explore the basics of dry stack stone and wet-laid stone so you can choose the best stone for your stacked rock wall or stacked stone veneer.
Dry Stack Stone: A Natural and Flexible Approach
Dry stack stone, commonly called dry-laid stone or dry stack, is a construction method that roots back to early human construction and solely depends on the principles of gravitation and genuine stonework for structural support. Dry stack stone is a system of arranging stones that do not require cement or material to join the stones together like in wet-laid stone. However, experienced stone masons work systematically to choose stones that fit each other perfectly in size and shape; thus, they do not require reinforcement. Usually, spaces between stones in a dry stack wall can be backfilled with gravel, which helps provide additional stability and drainage.
Advantages of Dry Stack Stone
- Natural Beauty: Dry-stacked stone walls have a very natural, often old-world appeal. Since no mortar joint is used in construction, the stones and bricks left are almost organic and blend very well with their environments.
- Flexibility and Movement: Dry stack walls have an intrinsic ability to move, which allows them to accommodate marginal ground movement without developing hairline cracks. For this reason, they are suitable for sites that undergo the freeze-thaw cycle or regions with seismological activities.
- Drainage: A dry stack wall has space between the stones, which ensures that water does not accumulate behind the wall and, therefore, diminishes the possibility of damaging the structure.
- Cost-Effective: Dry stack stone walls are relatively modest compared to wet-laid walls because they need less material and manpower. Since no mortar is used, this leads to a faster construction process and may, therefore, be cheaper.
- DIY Potential: Building a structurally sound dry stack wall requires expertise, but dry stack projects such as an interior stacked stone wall can certainly be undertaken by some DIY enthusiasts, given the right amount of prior research and direction.
Disadvantages of Dry Stack Stone
- Skill Required: Constructing a dry stack stone wall that is rigid and capable of repelling water requires a certain amount of finesse. Lastly, the choice of stones to place and where to place them is significant for the wall's stability and is very difficult, so it should be left in the hands of professional stonemasons.
- Limited Applications: Dry stack walls cannot be used for all projects where retaining walls with more support and strength are necessary. It is always critical to get professional advice before even considering erecting a dry stack wall in your project.
- Maintenance: After some years, dry stacked walls may face a problem of settlement or shifting of stones due to poor drainage or high traffic. Sometimes, minor touchups or other forms of wall examination might be needed to maintain the wall’s stability.
Wet-Laid Stone: Strength and Stability with Mortar
Mortared stone, also referred to as wet-laid stone, is one of the most conventional construction techniques. It calls for mortar to connect stones. The mortar creates a strong bond, thus improving the structure's structural stability. Wet-laid stone walls are often applied to build retaining walls, patios, walkways, and other structures that require high durability.
Advantages of Wet-Laid Stone
- Strength and Stability: Wet-laid stone walls are more durable and sound than dry-stack ones. This is because the mortar that holds the stones in position has formed a very well-consolidated structure with high load and pressure-bearing capacity.
- Versatility: Wet-laid stone can be used for many things since it can be utilised as load-bearing walls, walls for retaining walls, walkways, stairs, curbs, and much more. The mortar enables the bricks to be placed more accurately and at a more standard level than the other.
- Low Maintenance: In terms of maintenance, wet-laid stone walls are considered to need less attention than dry stack walls. Stones are fixed closer to each other by using a thin layer of mortar, which does not allow tufts of weeds and grass to grow between the stones. The overall surface is also less porous and easier to clean.
- Uniform Appearance: The wet-laid stone walls are more aesthetic as they have smoother and polished faces than the dry-laid stone walls. The mortar provides a distinct separation between the stones, which, when combined, give off a harmonised appearance.
- More comprehensive Material Options: Wet-laid construction is more flexible, meaning that more types of stone can be used. Due to the support offered by the mortar, more stones with a lesser degree of naturally complementary shapes and sizes could also be included in the construction.
Disadvantages of Wet-Laid Stone
- Cost: Wet-laid stone walls require mortar, which increases the amount of material needed and the time contractors spend constructing them.
- Drainage Considerations: Wet-laid stone is usually in walls where special attention is taken to its standard drainage in anticipation of moisture accumulating behind it deforms the entire wall. An adequate drainage system or a layer of gravel could be required.
- Limited Flexibility: Wet-laid stone walls are denser structures than dry-stacked walls, so while they are stronger under compression, they will probably crack if they experience large movements or shifting.
- Less Natural Appearance: Mortar used in the construction of stone walls appears less natural than dry stone stacked walls. If one wants to have that rural, natural look and feel, wet-laid stone walls are not the best bet, as they provide more of a polished look.
-
Less DIY Potential: Since it is hard to mix mortar and apply it properly in this construction technique, wet-laid stone construction is unsuitable for the do-it-yourself novice. Choosing the right mason is essential, especially for making the structure of the wet-laid stone wall strong and long-lasting.
Choosing Between Dry Stack Stone and Wet-Laid Stone
In conclusion, dry-stack stone and wet-laid stone are options based on the project requirements and style preferences. Here are some key factors to consider:
- Application: Wet-laid stone would be the best option for retaining walls that need more load-carrying capacity related to wall thickness. However, dry stack stone can be appropriate for aesthetic walls or soils with good percolation.
- Desired Look: Dry stack stone can be a good choice if you like a natural and more raw look to the stone. If you want your project to have a more official and even appearance, wet-laid stone may be for you.
- Budget: Dry stack stone walls are also more cost-effective than wet-laid walls.
- Maintenance Needs: Wet-laid stone walls are comparatively less maintenance intensive than the dry stack walls.
- DIY Potential: Construction and DIY enthusiasts, therefore, may think about using dry stack stone when undertaking small projects but only after adequate research and consulting. Wet-laid stone and dry stack require hiring a professional mason if the project is large or if it requires a lot of structural work.
Additional Considerations
- Climate: Pay attention to the climatic conditions within your region or appeal to clientele when drawing your conclusion. Dry stack walls may be ideal for locations with sound drainage systems and low chances of experiencing freeze and thawing.
- Skill Level: It is important to be reasonable when deciding whether going ‘DIY’ is possible for the specific job in mind. Building a dry stack wall of this nature is not something that should be attempted without adequate experience because it raises issues of structural integrity and safety and calls for potential large-scale repair work.
Conclusion
Dry stack stone and wet-laid stone are two great approaches used for years to build aesthetically appealing and practical stacked stone walls. Thus, when you know the pros and cons of each method, it will be easier to choose the most appropriate one that closely fits the project and design philosophy. So, if you want a more organic, earthen appeal or a highly refined, polished appearance, both dry stack stone and wet-laid stone can offer what you’ve been looking for when it comes to your stacked rock wall or stacked stone veneer.

Comments